(PDF DOWNLOAD) [Under the Persimmon Tree] Ø Suzanne Fisher Staples
Ile this makes her sad
she is able to cope While Telling Asma Faiz S Sister That She Is Her telling Asma Faiz s sister that she is her able to cope While telling Asma Faiz s sister that she is her and culture of choice she says The culture in which I grew up doesn t make me so unhappy now that I know what I believe in and what I value I know who I love and why My culture will always be with me wherever I go I believe this statement here is the essence of what makes this book a Notable Book for a Global Society I loved Staples book Shabanu but was disappointed in this one It is set in Afghanistan and Pakistan during 2001 2002 and is the story of a a girl and a young woman The woman converts to Islam marries an Afghan doctor and moves to Peshawar where she Islam marries an Afghan doctor and moves to Peshawar where she a refugee school and he goes off to run a clinic in northern Afghanistan The girl lives in rural Afghanistan and her family is killedconscripted and she ends up at the school in Peshawar So much of this story is unlikely and feels artificial The refugee school has 6 students there were thousands and thousands of refugees The woman chooses to put all her energy into the young girl when there is a woman in the school with who wanted to teach Afghan children why ignore her The wealth and class of the young woman compared withher students and the other refugees is irritating and made me angry The young woman s conversion to Islam seemed trite although there is a bit of information about Islam that would be good for discussion pretty thin though compared with ShabanuMay be worth reading since so little is available for young people about women and Islam and the middle east Overall I really enjoyed the book At first I wasn t too big of a fan but then once the family problems came into play I wanted to keep reading Every chapter switched between Najmah and Nusrat and that was a little confusing at the start because I didn t know what was happening The book was very upbeat and it has a good story behind it It shows how important family really is to people and that parents would do anything for their children This may not be a true story but this stuff really happens People lose their homes land and family members to war and that is horrifying I would definitely recommend this book to a friend It is only 270 pages and it is very meaningful The author makes you want to keep reading because you are so interested in what is going to happen next to these families The ending may be sad to some but it also shows the true value of family and what your family would want you to do Draining The first person present tense was unbearable It was whiny and unamusing I did not connect with a character who tells me everything This book starts out telling two separate stories one of a woman the other of a girl both living in the Middle East during Taliban seizure Najmah is the young daughter of a shepherd family living in a Northern Afghanistan village called Golestan Soldiers take Najmah s father and brother leaving her her mother and baby brother Later bombs take the lives of Najmah s mother and baby brother and destroy their family home Najmah heads to Pakistan in search for her father and brother Nusrat is an American Muslim who now lives in Pakistan with her husband who returned to his homeland to run a medical clinic and help his people in their time of need As Nusrat awaits his return in Peshawar she hosts the Persimmon Tree School to educate refugee children Their two stories merge as Najmah makes her way to Nusrat Both desperate to find lost Under the Persimmon Tree is about Najmah a girl of about eleven who watches the Talaban kidnap her father and brother and later her mother and baby brother are killed in an air raid At the same time the story of Nusrat originally named Elaine who is a blonde white girl from New York who met and married Faiz a doctor from Afghanistan Faiz hearing about the war in Afghanistan feels he must return home and help his people Nusrat returns with him and teaches school at a refugee camp in Peshawar Pakistan In alternating chapters these stories are told Najmah s story of traveling toward Peshawar and Nusrat s story of worrying about her husband who is helping his people in Mazar i Sharif Afghanistan and teaching the refugee children There is much discussion of the political climate in Afghanistan during this periodThis book is appropriate for grades 7 12 It could be read and discussed in discussions about the Middle East and Afghanistan in particular I hated this book If i could give it less than one star I wouldIt s plot line was the most confusing thing ever There were two stories happening at the same time and often switched between the two without warning I wouldn t really mind this if at least one of the stories was a good one but neither of them were There were both boring and didn t keep my attention at all If you are into confusing plot lines and boring stories then this book is for you otherwise find something else other than this waste of paper. O Pakistan Here she meets Elaine an American woman waiting for her doctor husband to return from the fron. I got to page 100 and stopped I ust can
t do it This godawful piece of garbage beat me I m actually wondering how I got this far There do it This godawful piece of garbage beat me I m actually wondering how I got this far There so many things wrong with this book that I m not even sure I can list them allA large amount of the sentences have an absence of commas making them either extremly choppy and short or so long that my internal voice even has to take a breath Either way it is exceptionally annoying A great example of this would be in page 7 where it bares the sentence of And only a
"moment later Baba an comes whisting down the path that leads from the pens that hold our sheep and goats at "later Baba an comes whisting down the path that leads from the pens that hold our sheep and goats at base of the foothills of the Hindu Kush That is one SentenceThere Is Also The is also the issue of how she uses the same word in a very short span of time It seems as if she was lacking a thesaurus as she was writing the bookA third problem I spotted had only occured once in the chapter but it caught my eye nonetheless It is a sentence located on page 12 which has been cut to spare the decent grammar and cut to the chase except for camels and donkeys and horses and people on foot There are three ands there Revist the first grade if you must How did this get past her editor Jeffrey Ward WHY Hey at least she used a commaAlso I John for Everyone: Part One, Chapters 1-10 just really don t like that the two separate stories are told in first and third person I have not gotten used to it yet and it s really aggravating If it s to easily depict who s perspective that part of the book is being told from it s not working You might be able to tell the difference from the names at the beginning of every chapter but what do I knowOn page 45 she used three uestion marks in a row For a book that is not proper At allIf that s even a word on page 46 hey they re right after each other Staples or rather Nusrat described the character Fatima as having bright dark eyes There s supposed to be some sort of poetic like description in there but that sust awfulOverall Uncle laughs too much In the span of three pages Staples said some variant of Uncle laughed five times That might ust be a personal thing but it bothered meOn page 62 within the span of a paragraph a day and a half passed by It was irritating to me at leastOn page 63 Najmah said the gazelle will turn into a fish referring the stars above her at the time and throughout her life twice in the span of a paragraphIn all of chapter 5 it was predictable at least to me that someone was going to die or get injured Or at the very least something bad was ought to happen Everything was too perfect the night before the bombing and Najmah had been gone for too longThere oh my Lord that took foreverHOW AM I SUPPOSED TO READ THIS This was an excellent book One of those books that I think everyone should read A book that should be on every school s reading list The book takes place roughly 2001 2002 in Afghanistan and Pakistan following two people one a shepherd girl from a fictional North Afghanistan village and the other the American wife of an Afghan doctor who is living near a refugee camp for Afghans in Pakistan while her husband works at a clinic in war torn Northern Afghanistan A series of probable events brings these two people togetherThe book shows Northern Afghan culture as well as a lot of the culture of Pakistan from the wealthy University professors to typical Pakistani to the poor and the refugees It also shows recent events in the part of the world in a realistic light The author was a reporter and did volunteer work in Afghanistan and Pakistan during this time period Although the reading level and tone of the book are suitable for 4 8th graders there is plenty here for discussion and thought for older students and adults When I was reading this book A long walk to Water popped up in my mind Their both so alike in so many ways two points of views and they both intercept child soldiers losing your family but finding them in the end and etc Under the Persimmon Tree really makes you look at things differently ust like A Long Walk To Water Also I like how this book some insight on how people lives are in India or Pakistan This book didn t disappoint me whatsoever and I hope that you get a chance to read this amazing book Under the Persimmon Tree by Suzanne Fisher Staples is a significant book to read to help promote a global society Due to the war in the Middle East and much of the media coverage done on it there has been a great misconception created about Islam and the majority of Muslims News and media has a tendency to focus only on the very worst Media can even exaggerate news in order to suit a specific agenda Due to this unfortunately many Muslims and middle easterners have been misrepresented Under the Persimmon Tree breaks down many of these fa ades with which so many middle easterners and Muslims have been wrongfully disguised by Under the Persimmon Tree has inclusion of minorities for a purpose One of the main char. Northern Afghanistan 2001 When the Taliban takes her brother and father to be soldiers and the bombing of.
Suzanne Fisher Staples Î 3 characters,
Acters Nusrat is a minority Nusrat s birth name is Elaine a name given by her parents who still live in Watershed New York Nusrat is Elaine s Islam name given to her by her husband from Afghanistan Faiz Nusrat translates to help in Islam Nusrat met her husband while getting her masters at Columbia and teaching in Manhattan Faiz a doctor in New York becomes distraught by the turmoil and disruption being caused by the Taliban and knows he must go home to Afghanistan to help Nusrat not wanting to stay without her husband and also desperate to help in any way possible Faiz to Peshawar
"pakistan where his family is seeking refuge in "where family is seeking refuge in AFFLUENT UNIVERSITY TOWN DISTRICT NUSRAT affluent University Town district Nusrat to live closer to the refugee camp so that she can help even though it is dangerous than living with Faiz s family At their home in Peshawar Elaine provides schooling for children at the refugee camp in Peshawar During this time Faiz has gone across the border all the way to North Afghanistan to run a clinic for the mujahedeen Afghans fighting against the Taliban in Mazar i sharif It is much dangerous in Mazar i sharif and Nusrat worries somberly for her beloved husband Under the Persimmon Tree does exceptional work of using uniue language Fisher Staples uses Dari in her work and often Dari is a language very similar to the Persian spoken in Iran Many languages have influenced Dari including Arabic Hindi Urdu and English Many of these words are also used in India Pakistan and other countries of the Middle East The Dari flows off the page in a way that the reader can likely figure out what the word means without having to look it up However if they do there is a glossary provided in the back of the book Below is a list of some of the most commonly used words in the book and their English translations Baba father Mullah a spiritual leader Naan unleavened bread baked in a mud oven Pattu woolen shawl worn by mean and women Saheba term of respectAccording to Tunnel et al multicultural books should Present a positive and reassuring representation of a reader s own cultural group Tunnel et al 193 Under the Persimmon Tree definitely has had a profound effect on me As a Christian there was a part at the end of the book that was very meaningful to me One morning Nusrat and Najmah are drinking tea when Nusrat tells Najmah that God will help them find out about her father and brother At this Najmah asks her What is the difference between Allah and the God of her childhood Nusrat replies They are the same I don t believe God cares by which language we name him I thought this was profound because I have often struggled with the same thought but have never been able to put it into words Tunnel et al also states that multicultural books should Foster awareness understanding and appreciation of people who seem at first glance different from the reader I have learned a lot about the Middle East and Muslims after reading Under the Persimmon Tree Due to the war in the Middle East 911 and much of the media coverage done on it there has been a great misconception created about Islam and the majority of Muslims News and media has a tendency to focus only on the very worst Media can even exaggerate news in order to suit a specific agenda Due to the fact that media only focuses on the Muslim fundamentalists or extremists much of the western world has been guilty of generalizing all Muslims in that negative light Under the Persimmon Tree has taught me so much about the Muslims who are staying to fight for their country their family and their tradition Under the Persimmon Tree is a very appealing in format It is a mostly picture less chapter book The one picture on the inside of the book is of a map of Afghanistan Pakistan and surrounding areas This map is located at the beginning of the book and I found it to be very helpful Under the Persimmon Tree talks about many different towns in Afghanistan and Pakistan especially when Najmah was traveling from her home village of Golestan in the Kunduz province The map served as a very visual representation to better understand how far Najmah traveled and how far away Nusrat s husband Faiz was One of my favorite things about this book is the glossary in the back This could be a great tool to use for the classroom The illustration on the cover of the book was not very meaningful to me until after reading it On the front there is a woman holding a persimmon gazing up at the stars The stars were very meaningful in this novel and were discussed a lot Najmah s name even means star There is also a shooting star on the back In the Middle East many people believe that to see a shooting star is a bad omen Nusrat taught Najmah that this was Betting on Ideas: Wars, Inventions, Inflation just a myth spread by evil people to strike fear in others in order to gain control over themAfter Nusrat discovers that her husband has died she decides that she must go back to her family in America Wh. Her tiny village kills her mother and baby brother Najmah makes a dangerousourney over the mountains ,